ESPN Q:: Is Eli Manning a Hall of Famer?

[Mikey Bananas]

Randy and TO for sure, Allen as well I may have missed someone but this was just off the cuff... I figured they had already retired and put them in the same category as Bettis/Martin etc

[SlickBri481]

agreed. Are there first ballot guys playing right now and if they were to retire today....... off the top of my head

Brady
LT
Ray Lewis
Ed Reed
Seymour
Vinatieri
Polamalu
Woodson
Hutchinson (dunno if he is still playing or not)
Peyton
Tony Gonzalez
Champ Bailey

Revis is pretty close already. 2 more years of this level of play and he's a lock

[eL FryEdo]

as of right now no of course not ... but hes on pace for it ... if the giants win next week and he plays a few more years like he did this year then yea you can lock up his ballot ... this get this win next weekend first ... GEEEE MMENNNNNNNNNNNNNNN

[Mikey Bananas]

Revis is pretty close already. 2 more years of this level of play and he's a lock

come on man really. Look at a guy like Champ or Woodson who have been doing this for a decade. Revis has been consistant for the last 3 years.. He needs about 4-5 more years like he had last year to be there.

[SlickBri481]

come on man really. Look at a guy like Champ or Woodson who have been doing this for a decade. Revis has been consistant for the last 3 years.. He needs about 4-5 more years like he had last year to be there.

Revis was a top 10 corner his rookie year, and was the best in football by year 2 (even if some fans had not totally caught on yet). If you think he's only been good for 3 years, you simply don't know what you're talking about. 2 more years at this level and he'll have 5 first-team All-Pros. Brady has 3, and only 2 first team. Not the same position, but still. The level of dominance cannot be ignored.

[eL FryEdo]

Slick reminds me of one of those carriage horses. He's got the blinders only sees what's in front of him and is fed shit In a pail on a daily basis

[SlickBri481]

Slick reminds me of one of those carriage horses. He's got the blinders only sees what's in front of him and is fed shit In a pail on a daily basis

Dude you're a freakin joke. You only started posting a lot when the Giants went on this run. I remember you quitting on them after the Saints game. I bet you barely even watched all year and now suddenly you're superfan that they're on a SB run. Fans like you are a fuckin joke. Frontrunner bandwagon toolbag, congrats. You know nothing about the sport and only watch select Giant games, even admitting to not watching the AFC CG, which is pathetic. If the Giants went 4-12 this season, you wouldn't have watched at all. You are the type of sports fan the avg person would expect to see on a nightclub message board, that says it all.......

[GuZzZ]

Slick coming back strong this friday afternoon

[Mikey Bananas]

hahah great post lol. I found it funny when he was going geeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee men. i honestly didn't see him post much all season..

also

i thought u giants fans didn't add the Ee's after that.. when i see that i see it like Gee thanks.

9 days out bros... psyched to say the least.

[SlickBri481]

Slick coming back strong this friday afternoon

I'm tired of all these "Johnny Giants fan" guys popping out of the woodwork

[GuZzZ]

I'm tired of all these "Johnny Giants fan" guys popping out of the woodwork

while i can vouch for Alfreydo's allegiance to Big Blue.........i do recall said Saints thread and the comments said poster made at the time

[Mikey Bananas]

who here are the Big Blue crew u speak of.. i know abs is a Jets guy and there was one kid 69er maybe who was huge on the dolphins being the team to beat the afc? is he still around?

[GuZzZ]

post #32 has the lulz

[Mikey Bananas]

not sure what you mean on that? Big Blue i am well aware of what that is, i meant who are your big Giants fans here. its usually giants/jets fans in a pissing contest about past accomplishments

[GuZzZ]

not sure what you mean on that? Big Blue i am well aware of what that is, i meant who are your big Giants fans here. its usually giants/jets fans in a pissing contest about past accomplishments

no worries....was not about you, but a particular subject matter you made reference to (sacred around these parts)

Giants..........Forca, Freydo, mike d, GSpot, Vito, myself

Jets....most of the jersey crew including Abs, Slick, Mav (RIP), Beach

[Mikey Bananas]

gotcha.. i figured that as much..

crazy we have another whole week of this crap

[eL FryEdo]

i bleed fucking blue dont give me that shit born bred and fucking raised .... it wasnt the saints game i think it was the redskins game i was bitter and said they should just shit out the rest of the season with the way they are playing and get some good draft picks because they looked like SHITTTTT .... of course im amped up now because they are playing great like they should be but im also right there to say someone looks like shit when they do so dont give me that shit ... fuck outta here son